The homework came back with an A. Three weeks later, the test on the same chapter comes back with a D. Your child swears they understood, and sincerely believes it. This gap is one of the clearest signals a parent can get, provided it is read correctly.
Stress rarely explains it all
It is the first explanation that comes to mind, and it is real. But a stressed child loses a few marks, not three grades. When the gap is that wide, the question is simpler: who did the reasoning on homework night?
Three ways to get homework right without understanding it
- The answer came from elsewhere: a classmate, an answer key online, an AI that writes out the full solution.
- An adult guided every step: the child followed along but never had to choose the method.
- The model was right there: the exercise looked like the one in class, and the child copied the form without grasping the substance.
In all three cases the homework is right and nothing has been learned. In the test, with no help and no model, all that remains is what the child can redo alone.
The test that never lies: “explain it to me”
Take an exercise they got right and ask them to explain, in their own words and without notes, how they found it. No trap, no grade: just tell the story of the method. Reasoning that was understood can be told, even clumsily. Borrowed reasoning stops after the first sentence.
A right answer proves nothing. An explained answer does.
What changes the results
- Have them explain at least one correct exercise each evening, not just fix the wrong ones.
- Two days later, redo an exercise they got right without looking at the first attempt.
- Let them be stuck for a few minutes before helping: that is where reasoning gets built.
- Replace “did you understand?” (the answer is always yes) with “show me how you do it”.
When Milo checks for you
Asking “explain it to me” every evening means being there and knowing the subject, which gets hard in secondary school. In MesDevoirsFaits, Milo does it every time: even when your child finds the right answer, he asks them to explain how. He never gives the solution for them, and your parent area shows what was really understood.
At the next test, the grade will finally say what your child can do alone. That is the only one that counts.